• HOME
  • solutions
    • RECURSION ANALYZERS
    • Mortgage Company Data
    • Recursion DataCloud
    • Customized Solutions
  • BLOG
  • CLIENT LOGIN
    • Recursion Analyzers
  • ABOUT US
    • OVERVIEW
    • OUR TEAM
    • News & Events >
      • Recursion In News
      • Recursion Data Citations
  • CONTACT
RECURSION CO
  • HOME
  • solutions
    • RECURSION ANALYZERS
    • Mortgage Company Data
    • Recursion DataCloud
    • Customized Solutions
  • BLOG
  • CLIENT LOGIN
    • Recursion Analyzers
  • ABOUT US
    • OVERVIEW
    • OUR TEAM
    • News & Events >
      • Recursion In News
      • Recursion Data Citations
  • CONTACT
BLOG

A Brief Update on the FHA Waterfall

4/10/2025

 
On January 16, 2025, FHA updated its COVID-19 Recovery Loss Mitigation Options available to borrowers to help them avoid foreclosure and sustain homeownership[1]. Briefly, there is a set of tools available to delinquent borrowers that allow them to return to making recurring payments. This is a complicated set of programs, but we break these down into three main categories:
​
  1. Partial Claims: For borrowers that have unpaid balances but can make payments, a “second lien” type of structure is created consisting of the unpaid balance that comes due when the “first lien” is terminated by a sale or a refinance. This process is known as a “Partial Claim”. A lot of loans are securitized into RG (reperforming) pools by Ginnie Mae. According to the FHA 2024 MMI Fund report, 1.4mm partial claims were applied during FY 2021-FY 2024[2].
  2. Modification: ​Should a borrower be unable to make payments following a partial claim, they may be modified to reduce balances going forward. The main modification is achieved by extending the loan term to as long as 30 years. Ginnie Mae securitizes these loans into Mod pools.
  3. Extended Term: Should available modification programs not allow the borrower to return to current status, a last-ditch option is to extend the maturity out to 40 years. These loans are securitized by Ginnie Mae into “ET pools”.
Below find a chart of 90+ day delinquencies by loss mitigation types, and a table showing the current market share of each as of April 1, 2025:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY

Read More

The Big Picture View on Delinquencies

7/1/2024

 
One of our ongoing themes is that pervasive structural change implies that traditional relationships between measures of market performance and economic fundamentals cannot be relied on to be stable over time. As a result, a broader view across markets is called for. Below see 90+Day delinquency rates as reported by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s Household Debt and Credit Report:[1]
Picture
​There are quite a few points to take away from this chart. Note the peaks around the time of the Global Financial Crisis (2009-2010) and the onset of the Covid Crisis (2020-2021). These correspond well with comparable spikes in the unemployment rate (10% in October 2009 and 14.8% in April 2020). But the composition is quite different. During the GFC mortgage, DQs spiked very much higher for mortgages than those for car loans, while the pattern was reversed during Covid. This can reflect differences in policy between the two periods (mortgage forbearance in 2021 but not 2011), but also, this likely reflects consumer’s views on the value of paying off different types of debt. In 2010, house prices were plummeting, so incentives to pay towards an underwater mortgage were low, but they needed their cars to get to their jobs, so they continued to pay off their auto loans. During the more recent Covid crisis period, homeowners in distress had access to forbearance programs.
 
This brings us to the more recent period. We see that delinquency rates across products started to rise in late 2022 across debt classes. Of note is the sharp increase in 90-day DQs for credit cards from 7.7% in Q4 2022 to 10.7%, above the Covid crisis peak of 10.0% in 2021Q1 and the highest reached since 10.9% in Q2 2012. Car loan DQs rose modestly from 3.7% to 4.4% over this period, while mortgage DQs inched slightly higher from 0.4% to 0.6%. The superior performance in mortgages is no doubt due to the post-Covid surge in house prices, which has created a powerful incentive for homeowners to stay current on their mortgages.
 
But the interesting observation is that these increases occurred even though the unemployment rate has remained less than or equal to 4.0% for the past 18 months. Clearly there is a class of distressed borrowers out there in this relatively strong labor market. Since the NY Fed data contains no detail at all in terms of these borrowers, we take a deep dive into mortgage delinquencies based on agency disclosures. We start by looking at total delinquencies of the total books of business for the GSEs and FHA:
Picture
It's interesting to note that the trend in all cases is flat-to-down, in contrast to the slight rise in the NY Fed data[2]. There are many possible explanations for this, including that our data do not contain VA or non-QM loans, and that the NY Fed data is based on a 5% sample while ours covers the entire universe of outstanding mortgages in the GSE and FHA programs[3].

For our purposes, the most interesting program is FHA since these borrowers tend to have lower incomes, lower credit scores, and less experience managing debt compared to other mortgage holders, implying that they have relatively higher vulnerability to adverse economic conditions[4]. The thing is, as mentioned earlier, conditions are not that adverse.

To find trends in distress in the FHA program we look at modified loans as these started out as loans that were determined to be unsustainable to begin with. In fact, performance here has deteriorated on trend over the past couple of years:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY
The 90-day DQ rate for these loans almost doubled from 4.1% in February 2022 to 8.0% in March 2023 and has been in a volatile but flat trend since that time. We look for fundamental trends to scale this trend, in general, from labor market indicators, which we feel is the key driver of mortgage performance. There are many such candidates, but here we look at the Kansas City Federal Reserve Labor Market Condition Indicators (LMCI)[5]. These indicators consist of 24 distinct labor market variables. The indicator we use is the LMCI Level of Activity index. It is scaled so that a number above zero indicates a stronger level of activity than the long-term average. In the chart above, we invert this indicator so as to see the correlation with rising distress in FHA modified loans. It seems that modified loans are sensitive to deceleration in labor market activity.
​
We can dig deeper into this phenomenon by breaking the data down into different categories:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY
​Here, we break the FHA universe into four categories: ET loans, mods ex ET, RG and other purposes. ET is extended term, which are generally 40-year mortgages. RG is Reperforming, which is not a mod but a loan leaving forbearance with a partial claim. All four categories exhibit quite different behaviors with ET loans displaying sharply worse performance than the other categories. It’s important to note that the ET share is quite small but growing:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY
The above chart points out that while looking at DQ charts is informative, they can be somewhat misleading in situations where programs have been around for different lengths of time. One way to get around this is to look at particular cohorts. Below find DQ’s for the 2022-2024 cohort:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY
It’s interesting to note here the stability in the Mod ex-ET and other categories. Growing distress is visible for the newer RG and ET programs, although the DQ rates for both peaked earlier this year.
 
Finally, another way of looking at distress over time in a consistent pattern across programs is via Early Payment Defaults (EPDs). These are the share of loans that experience two or more months of missed payments in the first six months after origination:
Picture
RUN UNDERLYING QUERY
EPDs jumped with the onset of Covid but quickly fell back after forbearance and other policy programs were instituted. More recently, we can see distress in the various mod programs while loans in the Other category exhibit little such behavior. This difference is interesting because the incentive to pay for more recently-originated mortgages is very much less than those prior to 2021 given the recent jump in home prices.
 
To conclude, examining the behavior of nonpayment of debt is a very complex task, which varies by loan class, and subclass. It depends on the financial health of borrowers, and the state of the economy, particularly with respect to labor markets. It is important to avoid making broad statements about trends in DQs without taking these factors into consideration. Finally, we do not see broad signs of distress in consumer debt markets (particularly credit cards) spilling over to mortgages, except possibly in the most distressed cohorts. We conclude that mortgages are not yet a source of general financial concern, but the situation needs to be closely monitored, particularly within the most distressed category of borrowers.

[1] https://www.newyorkfed.org/microeconomics/hhdc
[2] This contradicts a widespread view that FHA loan performance has deteriorated in recent quarters. In fact, the 30-day DQ rate for FHA has been in an upward trend over the past two and a half years. (To as high as 6.5% recently, according to FHA Loan Performance Trends Report). Most of these however, cure before hitting the 90-day threshold.
[3] See New York Fed Household Debt And Credit Report (https://www.newyorkfed.org/microeconomics/hhdc), p44, paragraph 1.
[4]  For 2023 issued GSE and FHA loans (disclosed by Agencies), the WA credit score is 754 vs. 676; while the share of first-time home buyer of purchase loans is 46.5% vs. 75.0%. In addition, according to HMDA 2023, the WA borrower’s income is $301k for conventional loans and $112K for FHA loans.
[5] https://www.kansascityfed.org/data-and-trends/labor-market-conditions-indicators/

A Deep Dive into FHA DPAs

3/6/2024

 
In a recent post, we reviewed the market for mortgages with down payment assistance features[1]. We noted that our loan-level data for FHA showed a rate that was about half of that reported by the FHA Portfolio Snapshot database.

Since the agency disclosures are at the loan level, we use this dataset to do a deep dive into which servicers are most active with this product and what loan performance looks like across institutions. Unlike the previous note, which covered all deliveries, here we focus on the market for new purchase mortgages.
​
Below find a table of the DPA usage for the top ten FHA purchase mortgage issuers in 2023, along with summary statistics for 2022 and 2021:
Picture

Read More

Proposed VA Loan Repayment Program

2/21/2024

 
On November 30, 2023, the Veterans Administration (VA) announced a new home retention program called the VA Servicing Purchase (VASP) program as an option for borrowers who cannot be assisted through other home retention options[1]. As the program will not be rolled out until March 2024, VA has strongly encouraged a foreclosure moratorium on all VA-guaranteed loans through May 31, 2024. Under this program, VA will exercise its statutory option to purchase the loan from the servicer and VA will hold the loan in VA's own loan portfolio[2]. The servicer will prepare a modification of the loan to increase affordability for the Veteran.

As the vast majority of VA mortgages are securitized in Ginnie Mae pools, let’s first take a look at the outstanding balance and loan count of VA loans using data disclosed by Ginnie Mae:
Picture

Read More

The Impact of ESG on the GSE Market

4/19/2023

 
Since the end of last year, the Government Sponsored Enterprises have released so-called “Social Score” Indexes that are made to appeal to ESG investors. Both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac produce scores at the pool level based on a variety of social metrics. The following methodology summary comes from Fannie Mae[1] (Freddie Mac has adopted the same methodology as Fannie Mae’s):

Read More

A Look at the Ginnie Mae 40-Year Mod

3/24/2023

 
With all eyes on the turmoil in the banking sector, it’s good to see that policymakers continue to innovate to help borrowers. Earlier this month, HUD published Mortgagee Letter 2023-06 “Establishment of the 40-Year Loan Modification Loss Mitigation Option”, which establishes the 40-year standalone Loan Modification into FHA’s COVID-19 Loss Mitigation policies[1]. The standalone 40-yr mod is scheduled to be implemented by May 8. This follows the establishment of a 40-yr modification with a partial claim in April 2022[2]. The introduction of standalone 40-yr mods reminded us that we haven’t focused on the progress of the 40-year mod with a partial claim identified by pool prefix “ET”. Below find a chart of issuance by program:

Read More

The Severity of Mortgage Winter

2/15/2023

 
In recent posts, we introduced the phrase “Mortgage Winter” to describe the current environment where high-interest rates and elevated home prices lead to a severe drop in transaction volumes[1]. Subsequently, we looked at the impact of this situation on individual market participants[2]. The bulk of market participants across the mortgage ecosystem is experiencing year/year revenue declines of two-thirds or more. These entities are having to adjust their business models to this situation and develop strategies to navigate the uncertain environment ahead.
​
Spring will come, but whether the ensuing rebound will be sufficient to return the sector to a state of financial health is a question that remains far from assured. There is also another factor to consider besides revenue, and that is the potential for increased servicing costs associated with delinquent borrowers.
Picture

Read More

Digging into GSE Buyouts

1/24/2023

 
​Growing concerns about a looming recession combined with increasing signs of distress in Government mortgage programs, particularly FHA, are leading many market participants to step up their focus on GSE buyouts. These found a recent peak last winter as forbearance programs unwound and have been in a generally declining trend since that time.
Picture
run underlying query

Read More
<<Previous

    Archives

    April 2025
    January 2025
    November 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    May 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019

    Tags

    All
    Affordability
    ARM
    Bank Call Report
    Bank\nonbank
    Borrower Assistant Plan
    Buydown
    Cash Window
    Climate Change
    CMBS
    CMO
    Conforming Loan
    Conventional Loan
    COVID 19
    CPR\CDR\CRR\CCR
    Credit Score\DTI\LTV
    Credit Union
    CRT\CAS\STACR
    Delinquency
    DPA
    Early Buyout
    Early Payment Default
    ESG
    ET Pools
    Fannie Mae
    Fed
    FHA
    FHFA
    Forbearance
    Foreclosure
    Foreign Investor
    Freddie Mac
    Freddie Mae
    FTHB\Repeated Purchase
    Ginnie Mae
    Green Loans
    GSE
    HECM
    HELOC
    HMDA
    HUD
    LMI
    Macro
    Manufactured Housing
    Modified Loans
    MSR
    Multifamily
    Multi-issuer
    Occupancy Type\NOO
    Partial Claim
    Payoff
    PIW
    Prepayment
    Property Valuation Methods
    PUD
    Purchase Loans
    Recursion In News
    Recursion In The News
    Refi Loans
    Reperforming
    Repurchase
    RG Pools
    RIN
    Rural Housing
    SEC
    Second Lien
    Single Family
    Special Eligibility Program
    TBA Market
    TIC
    TPO
    UMBS
    US Treasury
    VA

    RSS Feed

RECURSION

SOLUTIONS ​
Recursion Analyzers
​
Mortgage Company Data
Recursion DataCloud
Customized Solutions


ABOUT US  ​
Overview
​Our team
CLIENT LOGIN   ​
Recursion Analyzers

CONTACT

224 West 30th St., Suite 303, New York, NY 10001
Contact Us

Picture
Copyright © 2024 Recursion, Co. All rights reserved.​
  • HOME
  • solutions
    • RECURSION ANALYZERS
    • Mortgage Company Data
    • Recursion DataCloud
    • Customized Solutions
  • BLOG
  • CLIENT LOGIN
    • Recursion Analyzers
  • ABOUT US
    • OVERVIEW
    • OUR TEAM
    • News & Events >
      • Recursion In News
      • Recursion Data Citations
  • CONTACT